KiwiDisSaver

New Zealand Institute of Economic Research economist Trinh Le on the KiwiSaver scheme (HT: Matt Nolan):

KiwiSaver is merely a money-go-round. Over half of the savings are funded by taxpayers, in the form of the $1000 kick-start subsidy, matching contributions of up to $1040 per year and foregone tax revenue from ESCT (employer superannuation contribution tax) exemption. Most of the remaining savings are employers’ contributions and money that members would have saved in other forms.

Only 9-19 per cent of KiwiSaver balances are estimated to be from reduction in consumption.

That much “new” saving is hardly enough to cover the administration and compliance costs of implementing the scheme, and the deadweight loss due to taxation…

More on KiwiSaver from Phil Rennie at CIS.

posted on 26 May 2008 by skirchner in Economics, Financial Markets

(1) Comments | Permalink | Main

Next entry: The Collapse of the Development Expert Paradigm

Previous entry: Business Spectator Column